GAINESVILLE — Florida’s baseball season did not just come to an unceremonious conclusion against Troy, it unraveled amid a collapse of the Gators’ pitching staff and an offensive no-show during Monday night’s 10-2 loss in deciding game of the NCAA Regionals.
Read more Berkshire Hathaway buys homebuilder Taylor Morrison in first deal under new CEO
Kevin O’Sullivan’s team entered the tournament as the No. 8 national seed and positioned to host the school’s first Super Regional since 2023 in the Gators’ bid for their third College World Series appearance in four seasons. Instead, Florida (41-21) fell for the fourth time during a regional since 2021.
On paper, Troy was a huge underdog. The Trojans earned the regional’s No. 3 seed and slipped into the 64-team field as an at-large team out of the Sun Belt Conference.
But for two days at Condron Family Ballpark, the Trojans (36-30) were the superior team in every way.
“They outplayed us in two games,” O’Sullivan said. “They deserve to move on.”
A night after Troy recorded five home runs and 17 hits during a 16-11 rout to force a winner-take-all rematch, O’Sullivan sent out Cooper Walls, with the Gators’ pitching options limited after three games in three days.
Walls, a 6-foot-5 right-hander and Hawaii transfer, immediately struggled, managing just one strike on his first seven pitches.
Josh Pyne connected on his eighth pitch for a single. Two batters later, Troy star catcher Jimmy Janicki ripped a double down the right-field line to score two runners before Walls struck out the next two batters.
After Walls walked the first batter he faced in the top of the second inning, O’Sullivan sent in Caden McDonald, the team’s designated hitter and one of Florida’s better relievers.
“There were some other options, but Coop has started for us before,” O’Sullivan said. “We just didn’t get the start that we needed. Quite frankly, we just didn’t pitch well enough in this tournament.”
McDonald’s outing started well enough. Troy’s Jabe Boroff hit into a double play, and Houston Markham flew out to end the inning, beginning a scoreless four-inning stretch by the sophomore right-hander from Tampa.
Trailing 2-0, the Gators got on the board after Cade Kurland opened the bottom of the fifth inning with a double down the left-field line against reliever Benjamin Stubbs. Florida’s veteran second baseman scored two batters later on a single by Kyle Jones.
Read more Myles Garrett follows Micah Parsons’ path as the latest star player traded in his prime
In a regional where 36 home runs were launched in seven games — and each of the six previous games featured no fewer than 15 combined runs — the finale was shaping up to be a low-scoring, old-school affair.
But O’Sullivan then made another pitching change.
The longtime Florida coach swapped a tiring McDonald for Russell Sandefer with one out in the top of the sixth inning. Sandefer, a UCF transfer, walked the three batters he faced to load the bases, though, which led O’Sullivan to turn to senior left-hander Ernesto Lugo-Canchola.
“It’s always easy to second guess,” O’Sullivan said. “But I saw (McDonald) in the dugout and he looked gassed. I made a decision and obviously it didn’t work out.”
Lugo-Canchola, who struggled Sunday night in limited action, gave up five runs. A two-run single by left fielder Drew Nelson and a two-RBI double by Boroff book-ended a squeeze bunt RBI single where no one covered first base for Florida.
Troy ended the inning ahead 7-1, with the game effectively out of reach.
Florida did manage a run in the top of the seventh inning on a single by leadoff hitter Jones, scoring Landon Stripling. But with runners on first and second and facing a full count, Florida home-run leader Brendan Lawson hit an infield pop-up to second base to end the inning.
Troy added to its lead in the top of the eight inning on a three-run home run by Boroff, who broke open Sunday night’s game with a grand slam.
“It’s surreal,” said Boroff, who was named the regional’s most valuable player.
Before routing the Gators on Saturday night, Troy rallied from a 6-2 deficit to beat Miami 9-6. To earn their at-large bid, the Trojans made a run at the Sun Belt tournament title, beating in-state rival South Alabama twice in the double-elimination format to reach the semifinals. It was enough for Troy to join four other Sun Belt schools in the field of 64.
“No one does that two times in two weeks — come on,” coach Skylar Meade. “This team’s built for it.”
Troy’s mettle and hitting have set up an improbable Super Regional meeting on the Trojans’ home field against Arkansas-Little Rock (36-26). Little Rock, of the Ohio Valley Conference, was the No. 4 seed and champion of the Hattiesburg Regional at Southern Miss. Whichever school wins the Super Regional — both are the Trojans — there will be a surprise participant in the College World Series.
“It’s really tough in baseball,” Meade said. “Beautiful things do happen where unpredictability prevails. There’s a reason college baseball … the excitement is through the roof. It is an absolutely great thing for the sport.”
Read more 10 summer road trip essentials to make your trip easier
Edgar Thompson can be reached at [email protected]